Why the constitution isn't enough
An Irish company's constitution under the Companies Act 2014 binds the company and its members — but it is a public document, amendable by special resolution, and silent on the things co-owners actually fall out over: what happens when someone wants out, dies, divorces, stops working, or simply disagrees. A shareholders' agreement is private, amendable only with the signatories' consent, and written precisely for those moments.
What we draft into it
- Decision-making — reserved matters needing unanimity or super-majority (borrowing, new shares, selling the business, directors' pay)
- Share transfers — pre-emption rights so shares are offered inside first, and permitted transfers (family, holding companies) defined tightly
- Good and bad leaver provisions — what a departing shareholder's shares are worth and when they must sell, especially where shareholders also work in the business
- Drag and tag rights — majority can deliver a whole-company sale; minority cannot be left behind on one
- Deadlock resolution — escalation, mediation, and a chosen mechanism (shoot-out provisions, expert valuation) for genuine 50/50 impasse
- Valuation machinery — how shares are priced when any of the above bites; "fair value by the auditor" needs far more definition than it usually gets
- Dividends, information rights, restrictive covenants — and funding obligations if the company needs more money
When to put one in place
At incorporation, ideally; at any investment round, necessarily; and before any of the foreseeable stress events — a shareholder approaching retirement, a marriage, a sibling joining the business — at the latest. Retro-fitting an agreement during a dispute is usually impossible: the leverage has already crystallised.
Already in a shareholder dispute?
This page is about prevention. If the dispute has arrived — deadlock, oppression, exclusion from management — our company law practice acts in shareholder and director disputes: companysolicitor.ie.
Shareholders' agreement or constitution: where each term belongs
Some protections only work if they are in the constitution, because they need to bind the company itself and future shareholders rather than just the people who signed: share class rights, pre-emption on the issue of new shares, and restrictions on transfer that the company must enforce when registering a transfer. Others belong in the agreement because they are private or because they create personal obligations between the shareholders: leaver provisions, deadlock mechanisms, funding commitments, non-compete covenants and dividend policy. A well-built package amends the constitution to match the agreement, and includes a supremacy clause so that, between the shareholders, the agreement wins if the two conflict.
The family company
A large share of the agreements we draft are for family-owned trading companies, often where a parent is passing shares to two or more children, or where a sibling who works in the business holds shares alongside one who does not. The pressure points are predictable: how the non-working shareholder is paid (dividends against salary), what happens to shares on a divorce or a death, whether in-laws can ever hold shares, and how a child who wants out is bought out without the company having to borrow to fund it. These are the conversations nobody wants to have at the kitchen table, which is exactly why they should be had in a solicitor's office while everyone is still on good terms.
What it costs and how long it takes
A shareholders' agreement for a private company with two to five shareholders, together with the matching changes to the constitution, is quoted as a fixed fee in writing before work starts. The time is usually spent on the commercial decisions rather than the drafting: a first meeting to work through the issues list, a draft, and one or two rounds of comments. Where the shareholders have different interests, each should take independent advice on the final draft, and the agreement should record that they did.
How our fees work
You get a fixed quote in writing before any work starts — no hourly-rate surprises and no meter running while you think. If the scope changes, the quote is revised in writing before we continue. In contentious business, a solicitor may not calculate fees or other charges as a percentage or proportion of any award or settlement. How contract solicitor fees work in Ireland →
Frequently asked questions
What should a shareholders' agreement include for an Irish company?
At a minimum: how decisions are made and which need every shareholder's consent; what happens when a shareholder wants to leave, dies or stops working in the business; how shares are valued on any of those events; pre-emption rights on transfer; drag and tag rights; a deadlock mechanism; dividend policy; and restrictive covenants for shareholders who work in the business.
Is a shareholders' agreement legally required in Ireland?
No — and that is why so many companies don't have one until it's too late. The Companies Act 2014 constitution governs by default, and its defaults are not designed for your particular co-ownership.
We're 50/50 partners. What happens in deadlock without an agreement?
Potentially: nothing can be decided, the company drifts, and the ultimate legal remedies are blunt — including court applications and, in extremis, winding up. A deadlock mechanism agreed in advance is precisely what avoids that cliff.
Can a shareholders' agreement override the constitution?
Between its signatories, a well-drafted agreement effectively governs — and it should be prepared alongside matching amendments to the constitution so the two documents pull in the same direction rather than contradicting each other.
Talk to a solicitor who reads contracts for a living. Call Mary Molloy Solicitors today.
Whether you are drafting terms for your business, handed a contract to sign, or unsure what a clause commits you to, an early conversation costs little and prevents a lot.
📞 Call 01 5827148Try the Contract Risk Checker
richardoshea@marymolloysolicitors.com · Dublin: The Ormond Building, 31–36 Ormond Quay Upper, Dublin 7, D07 EE37 · Kilkenny: 2 Rose Inn Street, Kilkenny, R95 W58D
Monday to Friday, 9:00 AM to 5:30 PM — out of hours appointments available