What counts as breach — and what kind
A breach is any failure to perform a contractual obligation without lawful excuse. The law's first question is severity: breach of a condition (or a sufficiently serious breach of an intermediate term) entitles you to terminate and claim damages; breach of a warranty gives damages only. Repudiation — conduct showing the other party no longer considers itself bound — lets you accept the repudiation, end the contract and sue. Choose carefully: treating a minor breach as repudiatory, and walking away, can make you the party in breach.
The remedies
- Damages — the default remedy: money to put you where performance would have left you (expectation loss), limited by causation, remoteness (the two limbs of Hadley v Baxendale) and your duty to mitigate
- Debt claims — where the claim is simply for a price due, it's pursued as a debt: no remoteness, no mitigation argument, summary procedures available
- Specific performance — a court order compelling performance, granted where damages are inadequate; routine for land contracts, rare for services
- Injunctions — restraining threatened breaches (confidentiality, restraints) where speed matters more than compensation
- Agreed remedies — liquidated damages, retention funds, termination rights: check the contract before the common law
The clock: six years, usually
Under the Statute of Limitations, an action on a simple contract must generally be brought within six years from the breach (not from when you discovered it), and twelve for contracts under seal. Waiting also degrades everything else: witnesses scatter, companies dissolve, and the counterparty's ability to pay erodes. The strongest claims we see are the ones brought early with a clean paper trail.
What to do this week
Preserve everything — the contract, emails, texts, invoices, photos. Don't fire off a termination notice before advice: wrongful termination converts your claim into theirs. Quantify your loss realistically, including what you can mitigate. Then take advice on the route: most claims settle, and settle best when the first letter is precise — see letters before action. Construction payment disputes have their own fast statutory track through our construction practice.
Which court hears a breach of contract claim in Ireland
Jurisdiction follows the value of the claim. The District Court deals with claims up to €15,000, and within it the Small Claims procedure handles consumer claims up to €2,000 for a €25 fee without a solicitor (it is not available for business-to-business debts or most building work disputes). The Circuit Court hears claims up to €75,000 (€60,000 for personal injuries), and the High Court anything above that. Pitching the claim in the right court matters for costs: a claim brought in a higher court than its value warranted can be penalised in costs even if you win. Where the contract contains an arbitration clause the courts will generally stay proceedings and hold you to it, so check the dispute resolution clause before issuing anything.
How a breach of contract claim actually runs
- Assessment. The contract and the correspondence are read in full, the breach is identified by clause, and the loss is quantified under each head with the documents that prove it. This is also where we tell you if the claim is weaker than it feels.
- Letter before action. A precise letter identifying the breach, the loss, the remedy sought and a deadline. A large share of commercial disputes settle at or shortly after this stage, because a letter that reads like a pleading changes the other side's risk assessment.
- Negotiation or mediation. Where there is a relationship worth keeping, or the sums do not justify litigation costs, a mediated settlement is usually faster and cheaper. The Mediation Act 2017 requires a solicitor to advise you about mediation before issuing proceedings, and the court can take an unreasonable refusal to mediate into account on costs.
- Proceedings. A civil summons (District), civil bill (Circuit) or summons (High Court), followed by pleadings, discovery where needed, and a hearing. Debt claims for a fixed sum can use summary procedures that are quicker than a full trial.
- Judgment and enforcement. A judgment is only worth what the defendant can pay. Part of the first assessment is whether the other side is collectable: a trading company with assets, or a shell that will fold on the day judgment issues.
If you are the one accused of breach
The same analysis in reverse. Was the term actually agreed, or is the other side relying on something said in a meeting that never made it into the document? Did they perform their own obligations first, where performance was a condition precedent to yours? Is the loss they claim too remote, or did they fail to mitigate it? Was there a force majeure event, a cap on liability, or an entire agreement clause that cuts the claim down? Most claims we defend are reduced substantially on one of those points before any hearing. The single biggest mistake defendants make is ignoring the letter before action and letting the other side issue proceedings on their own timetable.
How our fees work
You get a fixed quote in writing before any work starts — no hourly-rate surprises and no meter running while you think. If the scope changes, the quote is revised in writing before we continue. In contentious business, a solicitor may not calculate fees or other charges as a percentage or proportion of any award or settlement. How contract solicitor fees work in Ireland →
Frequently asked questions
What damages can I claim for breach of contract in Ireland?
The measure is expectation loss — the position performance would have produced — subject to causation, remoteness and mitigation. Wasted expenditure can be an alternative measure. Damages for distress are rare in commercial cases; loss of profit is recoverable where within the parties' reasonable contemplation and not excluded by the contract.
Is it worth suing for a small debt?
Small claims procedures exist for modest consumer amounts; for business debts, a well-drafted solicitor's letter resolves a surprising proportion without proceedings. The honest cost-benefit conversation — what it costs, what you'd recover, how collectable they are — is the first thing we give you.
The contract was never written down. Can I still claim?
Yes — oral contracts and contracts formed by conduct are enforceable (with limited exceptions requiring writing, like contracts for the sale of land). The challenge is proof: quotes, texts, invoices, payments and performance all evidence the terms.
How long do I have to sue for breach of contract in Ireland?
Generally six years from the date of the breach under the Statute of Limitations 1957, and twelve years for a contract under seal. The clock runs from the breach, not from when you discovered it, which is why claims about defective work or undelivered services should be assessed as soon as the problem emerges.
Can I terminate the contract because of the breach?
Only for breach of a condition, a sufficiently serious breach of an intermediate term, or a repudiation. For lesser breaches you are confined to damages and must keep performing your own side. Terminating without the right to do so is itself a repudiatory breach, so take advice before sending a termination notice.
Can I use the Small Claims Court for breach of contract?
Only if you are a consumer, the claim is for €2,000 or less, and it falls within the permitted categories (faulty goods, bad workmanship in some cases, minor property damage, non-return of a rent deposit). Business-to-business claims, and most disputes about building work, are outside the procedure and go to the District Court in the ordinary way.
Do I have to try mediation before going to court?
You are not compelled to mediate, but under the Mediation Act 2017 your solicitor must advise you about it and swear a statutory declaration that this was done before proceedings issue, and a court may penalise in costs a party who unreasonably refuses to mediate. In practice it is often the quickest route to payment.
Talk to a solicitor who reads contracts for a living. Call Mary Molloy Solicitors today.
Whether you are drafting terms for your business, handed a contract to sign, or unsure what a clause commits you to, an early conversation costs little and prevents a lot.
📞 Call 01 5827148Try the Contract Risk Checker
richardoshea@marymolloysolicitors.com · Dublin: The Ormond Building, 31–36 Ormond Quay Upper, Dublin 7, D07 EE37 · Kilkenny: 2 Rose Inn Street, Kilkenny, R95 W58D
Monday to Friday, 9:00 AM to 5:30 PM — out of hours appointments available